‘Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery’ Review: Benoit Blanc Returns with a Twist

Imagine a compelling intersection of G.K. Chesterton’s Father Brown detective tales and John Dickson Carr’s locked-room mystery, The Hollow Man, all wrapped in a narrative that subtly critiques contemporary political figures wielding power through fear and outrage. This is the essence of Wake Up Dead Man, the third installment in Rian Johnson’s Knives Out series. Departing from the extravagant locales of Glass Onion, the latest film returns to the more intimate setting of a small Catholic church and rectory in upstate New York.

However, appearances can be misleading, and much like any effective detective story, this neo-Gothic narrative starts with a sharp and humorous edge, only to become overly intricate as the plot unfolds. The film’s pacing loses steam as the investigation progresses, revealing its complexities. Notably, Josh O’Connor emerges as a significant presence, portraying a former boxer turned priest, who becomes both a murder suspect and a partner to Benoit Blanc’s investigative prowess.

Benoit Blanc, characterized by Daniel Craig’s suave performance, returns with his signature elegance. His chemistry with O’Connor’s character, Father Jud Duplenticy, creates a delightful dynamic, showcasing their mutual enjoyment in solving this perplexing mystery.

Despite initially being skeptical about his investigative methods, Blanc finds himself wrestling with the case’s complexities that challenge his unwavering belief in rationality. This tension ultimately leads to a comedic climax that recalls the dramatic panache of Phantom of the Opera, all while being literally elevated on a pulpit during his final revelations.

The story introduces Father Jud, who faces disciplinary measures at Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude after a violent incident involving a local deacon. This incident sets the stage for encounters with a series of colorful characters, including Monsignor Jefferson Wicks (Josh Brolin), whose erratic behavior raises alarms within the parish.

The ensemble cast features the magnetic Glenn Close as Martha Delacroix, portraying a dedicated parishioner tasked with overseeing church operations, alongside other remarkable characters played by Jeremy Renner, Kerry Washington, and Thomas Haden Church. However, some notable actors receive limited development, leaving audiences yearning for more from this star-studded lineup.

See also

Pixels

·April 22, 2026

Netflix Gears Up for Live-Action Gundam Film Production

The film’s theological themes resonate throughout the lush backdrop of the church, exploring questions of faith and morality amid a suspenseful murder mystery. Despite some narrative shortcomings, the rapport between Craig and O’Connor remains engaging as they navigate the labyrinthine clues that challenge their belief systems.

With visually striking cinematography by Steve Yedlin and thoughtfully crafted production elements, Wake Up Dead Man presents a blend of humor, intrigue, and societal commentary. While the film may falter in its pacing and distribution of focus among its ensemble cast, O’Connor shines brightly in this role, cementing his status as a versatile and compelling actor.

Based on reporting by Hollywood Reporter. Read the full story at Hollywood Reporter.